Publications

School District's Consideration of Late Grievance Waives Timelessness Defect

January 5, 2004

This case involved the termination of Scott McCarty, a maintenance employee who contended he was fired in retaliation for having filed a workers' compensation claim. McCarty filed a grievance under the District's grievance procedure, but missed the internal filing deadline by a few days. No action was taken by the School Board on McCarty's initial appeal.

Two months later, McCarty filed a written request to appear before the School Board to present evidence and testimony regarding his termination. The Board granted McCarty's request and deliberated his case in a two hour closed session. The Board denied McCarty's grievance and upheld his termination because his grievance was untimely and, alternatively, based upon the evidence presented during his hearing.

McCarty appealed the Board's decision to the trial court and the School District moved to have the case dismissed on procedural grounds because McCarty had failed to timely initiate the grievance process. The trial court refused to dismiss the case, concluding that the School District had, by fully hearing McCarty's grievance on the merits, waived its timeliness objections. The Tyler Court of Appeals agreed with the trial court and held that the Board's decision to hear evidence and render a decision on the merits of McCarty's grievance constituted a waiver of the grievance filing deadlines.

The moral of this case is that no good deed goes unpunished. McCarty's initial grievance was several days late and the Board would have been entirely within its rights to summarily dismiss the grievance on this procedural ground. Instead, however, in an apparent effort to "take the high road", the Board heard his case on the merits. This gracious gesture resulted in an unintended waiver of the timeliness defect and fostered a corresponding lawsuit which the District will now have to expend time, money and resources to unnecessarily defend.

Firm Highlights

Publication

ADA Accommodations that Come with Fur and a Tail

Boa constrictors in the workplace?  Do we have to accommodate all employee pets?  Join HR attorneys Kevin Mosher and Laura Alaniz for a fun and informative discussion on pets in the workplace.   

Experience

Fifth Circuit Decision Secured In Civil Rights Case

Dallas partner John Ross, obtained a favorable decision from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on behalf of his clients, El Paso Hospital District and two of its nurses, on civil rights, constitutional, and...

Publication

The Trifecta: ADA, FMLA, and Workers Compensation

A look into ADA, FMLA, and Workers Compensation from both the HR and Risk Management side. How do they work together? Listen as Kevin and Senior Risk Manager of Patterson Companies, Maggie Hobbs discuss...

Publication

Interviewing Tips and Tricks

Publication

Flextime in the Workplace

Is flextime right for your office? How do you keep confidential information confidential when employees are working off site? Listen as Kevin Mosher talks to Bill Kelly, HR Director of Vinco, Inc., about piloting...

Event

ABCs of Employment

Publication

Paid Sick and Safe Leave

When you think of Texas do you think of mandatory paid time off laws? How would Paid Sick and Safe Leave affect your HR policies? Join Kevin and Erin McNamara as they discuss this...

Publication

Is Sexual Orientation Discrimination Unlawful? Supreme Court to Decide!

Listen to HR attorneys Kevin Mosher and Stephanie Rojo discuss sexual orientation discrimination and transgender discrimination issues and the exciting cases before the Supreme Court.  Will SCOTUS find that federal law protects employees and...