Shelby G. Hall

Shelby G. Hall

Senior Attorney
News

Thompson Coe Attorneys Prevail in Appellate Mandamus Proceeding

January 12, 2018

Thompson Coe recently obtained mandamus relief for client, GreCon, Inc., in a significant discovery dispute before the Fourteenth Court of Appeals.  Plaintiff in a personal-injury case refused to produce settlement agreements with co-defendants, despite Texas discovery rules requiring production of the relevant parts of any settlement agreements. In a tactic adopted with increasing frequency by plaintiffs’ attorneys, plaintiff argued the settlement agreements were only relevant for purposes of proving GreCon’s right to a settlement credit, and thus were not relevant until after trial. GreCon petitioned the court of appeals for a writ of mandamus after the trial court refused to order production of the settlement agreements.

On January 12, 2018, the court of appeals granted GreCon’s petition and ordered the trial court to compel production of the settlement agreement.  Although the three-justice panel did not unanimously agree on the reasons for the decision, all three agreed that GreCon was entitled to the entire settlement agreements before trial. Two of the justices concluded that the settlement agreements were discoverable in order to prove the right to a settlement credit, to determine whether a settling party had a bias or prejudice that could be the subject of cross-examination at trial, and to evaluate potential exposure and settlement strategy. A different two-justice combination reasoned that settlement agreements are presumptively discoverable and  plaintiff waived his right to oppose discovery of the agreements by failing to seek a protective order when it initially responded to GreCon’s discovery request.

Thompson Coe partner Wade Crosnoe and associate Shelby Hall represented GreCon in the court of appeals. Partners Jennifer Aufricht and Sean Hicks represent GreCon in the trial court.

Firm Highlights

Experience

Claims Handling & Litigation: 2021 Freeze and Power Outage Catastrophe

Publication

The COVID-19 Vaccine Part 2

The golden question: can you mandate the COVID-19 vaccine? EEOC has now given guidance surrounding vaccines in the workplace. Join Kevin Mosher and repeat guest, Stephanie Rojo from the Thompson Coe Austin office talk...

News Item

Thompson Coe Attorneys Argue Before the Texas Supreme Court

Experience

COVID-19 Response Team - Resources and Updates

News Item

Thompson Coe Among Most Active Insurance Litigation Firms in the US, Study finds.

Thompson Coe Cousins & Irons was named among the most active law firms for insurance litigation over the past three years, according to LexMachina’s 2021 Insurance Report. Other firms identified in the report include...

Publication

Concurrent Causation Is Key In Texas Storm Insurance Suits

The 2020 Atlantic hurricane season, which ran from June 1 to Nov. 30, was a record-setting year according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.[1] The season produced 30 named storms, including 13 hurricanes...

Publication

Recruiting in 2021

What is Robert Half’s process? How do they make sure that you get the best candidate for the role? Join Kevin and Andrew McNaughtan, Director of Legal Permanent Placement from Robert Half, talk about the candidate...

News Item

Thompson Coe Partner Gary Pate Wins Complete Defense Verdict in Bench Trial Involving Real Estate Dispute

Publication

The 2020 HR Recap

We’ve made it to the recap episode! The good, the bad, the ugly, and everything in between. Join Kevin and Elaine (Lainey) Luthens as they discuss it all including FFCRA legislation, OSHA, what they...

Experience

Thompson Coe Obtains Texas Supreme Court Victory in Shooting Accident Suit